Understanding the "Listerine Mouthwash Causes Cancer" Claim

Understanding the "Listerine Mouthwash Causes Cancer" Claim

Introduction:

It's unsettling when products we rely on daily, like Listerine mouthwash, are accused of posing health risks. This concern echoes the 2015 scare over Maggi noodles and their high lead content. Recently, Listerine has been scrutinized by researchers who suggest its regular use could potentially lead to cancer.

The Origins of Listerine:

In 1879, a doctor from St. Louis named his antiseptic formula after Joseph Lister, a pioneer in surgical hygiene. Initially, Listerine served various purposes: it was a disinfectant, a cleaning agent, a dandruff treatment, a hair tonic, a deodorant, and a remedy for different bacterial and viral infections. Over time, its use as an oral antiseptic was realized, leading to its popularity as a mouthwash that promised to eliminate germs and freshen breath.

The Alarming Headlines:

Many of us habitually use Listerine for a quick rinse, so recent headlines linking it to cancer are understandably alarming. However, it’s essential to understand the full context before disposing of your mouthwash. The connection between Listerine and cancer is more nuanced than the headlines suggest.

The Research Findings:

A study in Germany investigated whether mouthwash use could affect STI rates in gay men. The study had 59 participants who used Listerine Cool Mint daily for three months, followed by a placebo rinse for another three months. The researchers found higher concentrations of two bacterial species, Fusobacterium nucleatum and Streptococcus anginosus, in those using Listerine. These bacteria are known to be associated with oral and colorectal cancers.

The Journal of Medical Microbiology published the study, which noted that "Listerine use was associated with an increased abundance of common oral opportunistic bacteria previously reported to be enriched in periodontal diseases, oesophageal and colorectal cancer, and systemic diseases."

The Role of Ethanol in Listerine:

Some researchers speculate that the ethanol in Listerine might contribute to the increased bacterial presence, given the known connections between these bacteria and alcohol consumption. Professor Kenyon, involved in the study, suggested opting for alcohol-free mouthwash as a precaution.

Listerine's alcohol content, about 20%, is likely used as a preservative and a carrier for other active ingredients rather than solely for its germ-killing properties. While alcohol can kill germs, this concentration might not be enough to eliminate all oral bacteria, potentially leading to dehydration and a lack of beneficial salivary enzymes. This could create an environment where harmful bacteria like Fusobacterium nucleatum and Streptococcus anginosus thrive.

Listerine's Response:

The study's authors caution that their findings are not conclusive and call for more research. A spokesperson for Listerine’s parent company criticized the study for lacking important design controls and rigor, making it difficult to draw definitive conclusions about health impacts.

The study did not account for other factors that could influence oral cancer risk, such as diet, smoking, alcohol consumption, and existing oral hygiene practices. Additionally, the small sample size limits the generalizability of the findings. Some participants may have developed oral cancer before using mouthwash, a potential reverse causation not addressed in the study.

Conclusion:

Before making any drastic changes to your oral care routine, consult your healthcare provider. While the link between alcohol-based mouthwashes and cancer warrants further investigation, it's premature to label Listerine as a cancer risk definitively. If you prefer to avoid alcohol-based products, Listerine offers alcohol-free alternatives. More extensive research is needed to clarify any potential health risks associated with using Listerine mouthwash.

Content Image Source Courtesy:

https://www.businessinsider.in